POLISCI 158 · AI & Politics · Session 16 · Monday, November 16, 2026
| US leads | China leads |
|---|---|
| compute · chips · money · frontier models | open models · robots · power |
What about the other countries?
Session 14 scoreboard
Show of hands · we vote again at the end
Most countries will use AI. Few will make it.
ILO (2025), WP 140, Fig. 20 · CC BY 4.0
Jobs exposed to GenAI, by country income group: high 34% · upper-middle 25% · lower-middle 20% · low 11%
Exposure ≠ gain: “Infrastructure constraints (electricity, broadband), insufficient digital skills, the cost of technology”
Exposure = AI overlaps job tasks, “not the actual impact on employment”
ILO Working Paper 140, Gmyrek et al., May 2025 (Fig. 20)
Access -> productivity gains · no access -> falls further behind
“a potential widening of the digital divide and global income disparity”
An IMF projection from 2024, not a measured outcome
Cazzaniga et al., IMF Staff Discussion Note SDN/2024/001, Jan 2024
Share of working-age people using GenAI, Q2 2026: Microsoft’s “Global North” 28.8% vs “Global South” 16.2%
Vendor telemetry · North/South grouping not defined by Microsoft · use ≠ gain
Microsoft AI Economy Institute, Jan 8 and Sep 21, 2026
US: 5,427 data centers, more than 10× any other country (2025)
All data centers, not AI only · count ≠ capacity · white = no data, not zero
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 1 (Cloudscene data)
Public or public-private AI supercomputers, 2025: China 85 · Europe & Central Asia 44 · North America 41 · East Asia & Pacific 27 · Latin America & Caribbean 8 · Middle East & North Africa 3 · South Asia 2
Proxy for frontier training capacity · planned systems excluded · no sub-Saharan Africa line
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 8, Fig. 8.3.1 (Epoch AI data)
Figure design: Juuso Koponen
39 countries host any public cloud region; 30 with GPUs
As of early 2024 · public cloud only, six hyperscalers
Lehdonvirta, Wu & Hawkins, AIES 2024
Same chokepoint as Session 14
Value added by region, 2022
SIA & BCG, May 2024; Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 1
2025: US 59 · China 35 · South Korea 8
2003–25: no notable model on Epoch’s list from Latin America or Africa
Counted by author affiliation · curated list, not a census
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 1 (Epoch AI data)
Most countries: buyers, not builders
Chips, cloud compute, frontier models -> concentrated in a few places
Slides 10–14
Every government now says “sovereign”. Few mean the same thing.
Sovereignty = ability to self-rule AI sovereignty = ability to govern AI’s national impact AI Index: “a state’s capacity to act deliberately and make independent decisions over … AI systems within its jurisdiction”
“AI sovereignty is an ambiguous concept” (World Bank)
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 8 §8.3; World Bank, WDR 2026, ch. 6, fn. 15
One framework of several · AI Index uses five layers (infrastructure, data, model, application, talent)
Data localization measures, cumulative to 2024: East Asia & Pacific 77 · sub-Saharan Africa 71 · Europe & Central Asia 66 · North America 3
Counts measures, not strictness · regional totals hide country variation
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 8 (data: Ferracane); World Bank, WDR 2026, ch. 6
Fine-tune an open model -> national model, foreign base
| National model | ← Base model | Base origin |
|---|---|---|
| Qwen-SEA-LION-v4.5-27B-IT (AI Singapore) | Qwen3.6-27B | China (Alibaba) |
| Gemma-SEA-LION-v4-4B-VL (AI Singapore) | Gemma 3 4B | US (Google) |
| Nemotron-SEA-LION-v4.8-120B (AI Singapore) | Nemotron 3 Super 120B | US (NVIDIA) |
| Apertus-SEA-LION-v4-8B-IT (AI Singapore) | Apertus 8B | Switzerland |
| Sarvam-M (India) | Mistral Small 3.1 | France |
| Sahabat-AI Gemma2 9B (Indonesia) | Gemma 2 | US (Google) |
Base models as listed on Hugging Face model cards, 2024–26
Hugging Face model cards
Brazil v. X, 2024
A platform case, not an AI one
STF, Sep 2, 2024; CNN Brasil and TELETIME, Oct 8, 2024
“African languages trail English by 30 percentage points … on average”
Models from 2024–early 2025 · reasoning models narrow the gap
Lundin et al., “The Token Tax,” AfricaNLP 2026
Bhashini figures self-reported · Masakhane benchmarks date from 2020
PIB, Feb 10, 2026; Nekoto et al., Findings of EMNLP 2020
Rendering via TechAfrica News (Aug 4, 2026); attributed to Cybastion
$170M package
$66.1M data center
$170M package, US EXIM-financed: national data center + government digitization platform + border surveillance system
How the $170M splits is not public
TechAfrica News, Jul 17, 2026; US EXIM, Aug 21, 2025; DCD, Sep 9, 2026
UAE · Stargate UAE: 1 GW planned, 200 MW first phase announced for 2026
Saudi Arabia · HUMAIN (Public Investment Fund) + NVIDIA chips · Mistral for Arabic models
Announcements, not delivered capacity · 200 MW live status unconfirmed, Nov 16
OpenAI, May 22, 2025; Reuters via Al-Monitor, Jul 2026; NVIDIA, May 13, 2025; Mistral, Aug 24, 2026
IndiaAI Mission (Mar 2024): ₹10,371.92 crore over five years
Government self-report · onboarded ≠ state-owned
PIB backgrounder, Feb 10, 2026; Sarvam AI, Mar 6, 2026
EuroHPC: 19 AI Factories + 13 Antennas, shared across member states
National champion: Mistral (France), open weights
Gigafactories chosen in early 2027 · call deadlines Dec 3, 2026 (Lot 2), Feb 4, 2027 (Lot 1)
EuroHPC JU, Jul 30, Sep 1 and Nov 5, 2026; Mistral, 2026
Malaysia hosts
Johor: “$35 billion beneficiary” of Singapore’s 2019–22 moratorium
Peninsular data centers need 8,391 MW by 2030 · Johor 4,428 MW
Permit rule on US AI chip exports and transits (Jul 2025)
Singapore builds
SEA-LION: open, state-funded model · S$70M initiative
Two neighbours, two strategies · Malaysia’s own models not covered here
Reuters via Khaleej Times, Jul 26, 2026; PETRA via The Vibes, Oct 20, 2026; MITI, Jul 14, 2025; IMDA, Dec 4, 2023; AI Singapore model cards
| Case | Compute | Models | Jurisdiction | Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Côte d’Ivoire | ● | |||
| Gulf (UAE, Saudi Arabia) | ● | ● | ● | |
| India | ● | ● | ● | |
| Europe | ● | ● | ||
| Brazil (X case) | ● | |||
| Southeast Asia | ● | ● | ● |
Each buys some tests. None buys all.
● = test the flagship move targets, not how well it does
Slides 21–28
“pursuing ‘AI sovereignty’ comes at a high cost and with uncertain benefits”
World Bank, WDR 2026 web page (ch. 6 summary) and ch. 6
“Narratives around AI sovereignty are often driven by foreign technological companies”
World Bank, WDR 2026, ch. 6, fn. 17; US EXIM, Aug 2025; Mistral, Sep 2025 and Sep 2026; The National/Reuters, Oct 22, 2026
Assigned country cards:
You audit the country; nobody speaks for it · written answers welcome
| Country | Compute | Models | Jurisdiction | Performance | Fix to fund |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| India | |||||
| UAE | |||||
| France | |||||
| Côte d’Ivoire | |||||
| Brazil | |||||
| Indonesia |
Rules travel too: by copying, competing and pressure.
2024: more than half of newly adopted strategies came from emerging economies
Strategy = policy intent, not implementation · the map shows year of adoption, not income group
Stanford HAI, AI Index 2026, ch. 8 (Oxford Insights data)
Which one is at work on the next slides?
Simmons, Dobbin & Garrett (2006), International Organization
De facto: firms “standardize their production globally and adhere to a single rule”
De jure: firms then “lobby their domestic governments to adopt these same standards”
Bradford, Northwestern University Law Review, 2012
| Travelling | Partial | Limited |
|---|---|---|
| Brazil PL 2338/2023: “excessive” and “high” risk tiers · passed Senate Dec 2024 · not law | South Korea AI Basic Act, in force Jan 22, 2026: “distinct from the more prescriptive EU model” | “a limited Brussels Effect” (Engler 2022) |
| Prediction: de facto + de jure effects “likely for parts” (Siegmann & Anderljung 2022) | Effect likely, but a “side effect” undercuts EU values (Almada & Radu 2024) |
Studies mostly 2022–24 predictions · EU delayed its own high-risk rules to Dec 2027 / Aug 2028
Senate and Chamber of Brazil; US ITA, May 29, 2026; Brookings, Jun 2022; GovAI, Aug 2022; German Law Journal, 2024; Regulation (EU) 2026/1744
EO 14320 (Jul 23, 2025): export “full-stack American AI technology packages”
Program renamed “SI Exports” (EO 14434, Sep 2026) · 78 applications, no designations found as of Nov 16
Federal Register, Jul 28, 2025; ITA, Apr 1 and Jul 6, 2026; EO 14434
China promotes WAICO “to help countries of the Global South keep pace with the global intelligent transformation, bolster capacity building and avert a new AI divide” Wang Yi, Jul 17, 2026 (MFA readout)
Action Plan (Jul 2025): “assist the Global South in truly accessing and utilizing AI”
WAICO, founded Jul 16, 2026: 29 signatories, 35 by Jul 31 · HQ Shanghai
Open models: Chinese models = 41% of Hugging Face downloads (Feb 2025–Feb 2026)
WAICO founding list only partly published · “Global South” is Beijing’s term
MFA PRC, Jul 2025 and Jul 17, 2026; Xinhua, Jul 17, 2026; TPRA Sudan, Jul 31, 2026; Hugging Face, Mar 17, 2026
Jul 2024
African Union Continental AI Strategy, endorsed by Executive Council
Aug 26, 2025
UN resolution A/RES/79/325, adopted by consensus -> Scientific Panel (40 members) + Global Dialogue
Sep 25, 2025
Global Dialogue on AI Governance launched (UNGA80, New York)
Jul 1, 2026
Panel’s first report
Jul 6–7, 2026
first Global Dialogue, Geneva
African Union, Jul 2024; UN General Assembly, Aug 2025; UN Global Dialogue site; UN Geneva, Jul 2026
Rules on paper ≠ capacity to use or enforce them
Left: where we found documented government use · Right: a readiness index’s public-sector adoption score
G3O = instructor’s own project; English-language search; not documented ≠ not used · pillar = index score, not measured use
Oxford Insights, Government AI Readiness Index 2025 (Dec 2025); G3O, as of Nov 4, 2026
44 laws
37 authorities
Of 54 African countries: 44 have a data protection law, 37 an operational authority (CIPIT, Apr 2026).
Counts differ across trackers (44–45 laws; 37–39 authorities)
CIPIT, Strathmore University, Apr 2026; Auditor-General of Kenya, ODPC report FY2024/25
Vote again: widen or narrow?
Peer Review 2 · Sun, Nov 22, 11:59 p.m. · 150–200 words
Wednesday, Nov 18: AI Agents: Reliability, Safety, and Governance · Yiqing Xu
Final presentations · Mon, Nov 30 / Wed, Dec 2 · 5 minutes, 3 slides
Peer Review 3 · in session, Nov 30 / Dec 2
Stanford University · POLISCI 158